View high resolution
‘Something remarkable is happening’.
‘A true urban heart & soul’.
Apparently.
If you’ve been to Leeds recently, you’ll have probably seen the great big new shopping centre that is going up pretty quickly in the city centre. Welcome to Trinity Leeds. Read the press releases and it seems that Trinity is the regional economic embodiment of a more famous Messianic member of a different Triune collective. Don’t be under any illusions, the message appears to be - in 2013 we will witness a 21st century resurrection of economic fortunes, bringing much-needed prosperity to an ever-growing metropolitan district, and the completion of a period of regeneration, the likes of which we are unlikely to witness again.
That’s the official bit. 1000 construction workers will have benefitted. 3000 more retail jobs will be created. And I’m sure it will look great. I’m not against it in principle at all. I really hope it succeeds (it can’t afford not to).
My problem is the messages that are being sent out as a result. In these challenging times for many, it’s comforting to know that come Spring 2013, our ‘retail soulmate will have arrived’. With so much economic and employment instability around, it’s heartening to know that there’ll be an even bigger, even greater, shiny, cathedral of retail, offering ‘the ultimate shopping experience’ for worshippers drawn to a ‘beacon of retail excellence’.
Because clearly at the moment, our current travails centre on the fact that we are lacking in soulmates (a person with whom one has a strong affinity - dictionary.com) and the answer to this conundrum is to flock towards the city centre to part with more and more of the cash we have less of, in an attempt to find the ever-illusive happiness we crave, aligning our souls with a building rather than a person, whilst attempting to reignite an economy reliant on spending more than we have. The message is simple: spend/have more = be happy.
But all we have to do is read the papers and watch the news, to see that we’ve been trying that one for quite a while, and sooner or later the money runs out.
Our culture places so much emphasis on the next big thing. We have to keep on making something bigger. Something better. We’re never quite satisfied with what we have. We have an insatiable desire for the huge, the imposing, the statement-maker. It’s not enough, for instance, to have an exciting, vibrant, people-centred music scene if Coldplay, Adele and U2 can’t be accommodated in venues with a sub-13000 capacity.
There must, however, be a limit. Things just can’t keep on being bigger.
Trinity’s overview of the project contains all the buzzwords that the PR-people have run through Thesaurus.com - ‘stunning opportunity; prestige, distinction, unparalleled shopping environment; expressive; stylish destination’…etc.
But…it seems to me that our hearts are sick with an imposed need to define ourselves by what we have, and I’m as bad as anyone writing this on my Mac, having captured the picture on my iPhone. But the more I think about it, I just don’t think it will cut it. I hope it works for Leeds. I love Leeds. I haven’t got a solution.
But Land Securities (Trinity’s holding company) tell us that ‘Leeds is being defined by the delivery of the most important city centre development of recent times‘ (their emphasis). Leeds can’t afford it - morally, let alone monetarily - to be defined by, to find it’s identity and it’s salvation, in the simplistic, soulless, soulmate of shopping.
I know someone who wrote a book, in which a central premise is along the lines of ‘the best things in life aren’t things’. Sounds about right to me.










